Until 18th March, 2022, TBA had been awaiting a decision on the question of jurisdiction in the Land Court. This had arisen because in April 2021 Waratah Coal advised that it had revised its mine plan and does not presently intend to undertake open cut mining on Bimblebox Nature Refuge.
The proposal to underground mine beneath BNR has not changed, with attendant issues of concern such as subsidence impacts on water and surface ecosystems and habitat conditions for flora and fauna.
The Land Court ruled it can and should hear the application and objections based on the revised mine plan. (https://www.queenslandjudgments.com.au/caselaw/qlc/2022/3)
The Qld Land Court hearing on our case against Waratah Coal started on 20th April 2022, with a visit to Bimblebox Nature Refuge by representatives from all parties: President Kingham and her associates, Department of Environment and Science, Environment Defenders Office, Waratah Coal, and the Department of Natural Resources and Mines.
This autumn has been unusually wet but the rain gods allowed the tour to slot in between two rain events and the tracks were dry.
TBA provided accommodation for DES and EDO, the latter camping in tents – good on them!. (All parties were originally invited to stay at BNR.) Self-represented active objector John Brinnand was also present for the tour, which was done in a convoy of 4WDS with BNR carer Ian Hoch as guide. It seemed to all go very well.
Much work had to be undertaken to prepare for the visit, and several volunteers helped with this beforehand, during and after the event. Work included clearing the tracks (10 km or so) of termite mounds and logs, and sprucing up the art camp, the new tent for which only arrived a few days before.
TBA packed lunches for all participants to have at the camp. Uncle Adrian Burragubba together with Coedie, Nathan, Abraham and Kaylee-Ann set up a Bora ring at the artist camp and welcomed the Court and the parties to Country with a smoking ceremony as well as performing dances. Coedie shared an introduction to Jagalingou lore, drawing upon aspects of the right to culture and the importance of protecting Country and placing people in context as a component of the environment. President Kingham acknowledged the significance of the ceremony, and noted that it is the first time the Land Court has been welcomed to Country during a site inspection for a mining objections hearing;
Everyone was moved by them. Adrian drove all the way from Brisbane just for this and we are very grateful.
As you may have read, the Court made a landmark decision to travel to the Torres Strait to hear on country evidence: a first. (https://archive.sclqld.org.au/qjudgment/2022/QLC22-004.pdf)
Another first in this case is that a Nature Refuge is objecting to being mined!
The actual hearing starts on Tuesday 26th April in Brisbane and is expected to run for about six weeks. This will be a great opportunity for TBA members and friends of Bimblebox to hear the opening statements of the parties. Youth Verdict will have a presence outside the court.
Any media or updates will be posted on our website, FB page and twitter.
The proposed timetable for the coming week is as follows. Please note that this is just a proposal and must be subject to some flexibility to accommodate for uncertainty.
Hearing – week one
26 April | 27 April | 28 April | 29 April |
Morning:
Waratah Opening Address – 10 mins YVL/TBA Opening Address – 1 to 1.5 hours
Afternoon: Brinnand Opening Address – 30 minutes DES Opening Address – up to 30 minutes
Objections to Evidence – 30 minutes
(Nui Harris on Standby) |
Morning:
Nui Harris (Waratah) – 1 day (YV TBA X-XXN 4 hours)
Afternoon: Nui Harris (Waratah) (DES X-XXN 20mins)
(Natasha McIntosh on standby) |
Morning:
Natasha McIntosh (Waratah) (80 minutes) (DES X-XXN 10mins)
Afternoon: Concurrent Evidence – Ross Seedsman and Phillip Pells (Subsidence) (120-150 minutes TBA/YV)
(Subsidence on standby to start after McIntosh in the morning) |
Morning:
Concurrent Evidence – Ross Seedsman and Phillip Pells (Subsidence) (WAR X-XN 60 – 120 mins)
Concurrent Evidence – Ross Seedsman and Phillip Pells (Subsidence) (DES X-XXN 30mins)
Ross Seedsman and Phillip Pells (Subsidence) + Noel Merrick (1 hour TBA/YV) |
Public attendance
Members of the public are welcome to attend the Land Court on Level 8 of the Magistrates Court Building, 363 George St, Brisbane City QLD 4000 in Court Room 40. Persons can check the daily law list for court room and attendance details the day prior: https://www.courts.qld.gov.au/daily-law-lists/daily-law-lists#LCQ
Members of the public will be able to attend by phone as follows:
02 8310 4080 (for other countries check web browser link)
Use conference code: 24725270#
If you are passing on these details, please be sure to include the following message:
If you are joining the hearing by audio connection, please ensure that your microphone is turned off, as sound can be heard in the court room.